Frequently Asked Questions: Challenging Child Maintenance Service (CMS) Decisions
I think the CMS calculation is wrong. What can I do?
If you believe the amount of child maintenance has been calculated incorrectly, you can ask the Child Maintenance Service (CMS) to explain how the calculation was made. You may be able to challenge the decision if, for example:
-
Income information is incorrect or out of date.
-
The number of overnight stays has been recorded incorrectly.
-
Other children living in the paying parent's household have not been taken into account.
-
There has been a mistake in applying the rules.
It is important to act quickly, as there are time limits for challenging decisions.
What is a Mandatory Reconsideration?
A Mandatory Reconsideration is the first step in challenging most CMS decisions. This means asking the CMS to look at its decision again because you believe it is wrong.
You should explain:
-
Which decision you disagree with.
-
Why you think it is incorrect.
-
Any evidence you have to support your position.
The CMS will review the decision and send you a new decision if the outcome changes.
How long do I have to challenge a CMS decision?
You should normally request a Mandatory Reconsideration within one month of the decision. If more time has passed, you may still be able to challenge the decision in certain circumstances, but you should seek advice as soon as possible.
What evidence can I provide?
Useful evidence may include:
-
Payslips or employment information.
-
Tax returns or self-employment accounts.
-
Evidence of overnight childcare arrangements.
-
Proof of shared care.
-
Bank statements.
-
Correspondence showing changes in circumstances.
Providing clear evidence can increase the chances of the decision being changed.
What if I disagree with the Mandatory Reconsideration decision?
If the CMS does not change the decision, or you are still unhappy with the outcome, you may be able to appeal to the First-tier Tribunal.
An independent judge will consider the evidence and decide whether the CMS decision was correct.
Can I appeal every CMS decision?
Not every decision carries a right of appeal. However, many decisions relating to child maintenance calculations, liability and certain variations can be challenged.
It is worth seeking advice if you are unsure whether a decision can be appealed.
What is a variation and can I challenge one?
A variation is a request to change the standard child maintenance calculation because of special circumstances.
Examples include:
-
Additional income not included in the calculation.
-
Diversion of income.
-
Assets that generate income.
-
Special expenses such as costs associated with contact arrangements.
If the CMS refuses a variation application, or allows one that you believe is unfair, you may be able to challenge that decision.
What if the paying parent is self-employed?
CMS calculations are usually based on income information supplied by HM Revenue & Customs. If you believe a self-employed parent is earning more than their declared income suggests, you may be able to ask the CMS to investigate whether a variation should apply.
Evidence of additional income, assets or lifestyle may help support your case.
Can I challenge arrears or enforcement action?
Yes. If you believe arrears have been calculated incorrectly, or that enforcement action has been taken in error, you may be able to ask the CMS to review the decision and provide an explanation of how the arrears were calculated.
Seek advice quickly if enforcement action is being taken, as deadlines can be short.
What happens if my circumstances change?
You should tell the CMS as soon as possible if circumstances change, such as:
-
A change in income.
-
A change to shared care arrangements.
-
A child leaving full-time education.
-
Changes to who the child lives with.
If the CMS fails to take a reported change into account, you may be able to challenge the decision.
Can Shropshire McKenzie Friend Services help me challenge a CMS decision?
Yes. We can help you understand the decision, identify whether there may be grounds to challenge it, explain the reconsideration and appeal process, and help you gather evidence to support your case.
If you are concerned about a CMS decision, seek advice as soon as possible to avoid missing important deadlines.
